article photo 1

Paddlers Get Their Day In Court on Chattooga

Posted: 10/14/2010
By: Kevin Colburn

 

Yesterday, conservation-oriented paddlers presented their case against the US Forest Service regarding the agency's illegal paddling ban on 21 miles of the Wild and Scenic Chattooga River in a federal district court hearing.  The full line-up of regional paddling clubs and national organizations (ACA and AW) were present and were represented by superb pro-bono legal council. 

 

Life-long Chattooga River paddler Bruce Hare offered moving testimony on the value of the Chattooga River and the irreparable impacts of the boating ban.  Pro bono council offered compelling legal arguments focused on the agency's admitted violation of the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act and the agency's futile and flawed process.  Just last week the USFS formally cancelled their five year attempt to conduct a user capacity analysis and reach a new decision.  They announced that they are starting the multi-year process over.  Council for the Agency confirmed in court that this new process could take years and would likely result in a continuation of the boating ban. 

 

The hearing was focused on motions to dismiss the paddler's case, and on the paddlers' request for a preliminary injunction that would immediately require legal and nationally consistent management of the Chattooga River.  The Honorable Judge J. Michelle Childs heard roughly four hours of arguments and testimony, and stated that she would issue a decision at a later date. 

 

The Upper Chattooga River is a Wild and Scenic River that passes through a Wilderness Area in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia.  Paddlers have sought protective, legal, and nationally consistent management of the Upper Chattooga river since at least 1995. 

Kevin Colburn

Asheville, NC

Full Profile

Associated Projects

Chattooga Headwaters (NC)

The US Forest Service has banned boating on the upper 21 miles of the Wild and Scenic Chattooga River.

Clubs

7.4.3PHP Version1.23sRequest Duration9MBMemory UsageGET content/{url}Route
    • Booting (38.83ms)
    • Application (1.2s)
    • 1 x Application (96.85%)
      1.20s
      1 x Booting (3.15%)
      38.83ms
      20 templates were rendered
      • page.river-summary.components.level-legend (resources/views/page/river-summary/components/level-legend.blade.php)5blade
        Params
        0
        css
        1
        RiverColors
        2
        id
        3
        options
        4
        formRenderService
      • legacy.views.container-view (resources/views/legacy/views/container-view.blade.php)6blade
        Params
        0
        components
        1
        controls
        2
        id
        3
        class
        4
        title
        5
        formRenderService
      • legacy.views.container-view (resources/views/legacy/views/container-view.blade.php)6blade
        Params
        0
        components
        1
        controls
        2
        id
        3
        class
        4
        title
        5
        formRenderService
      • legacy.views.container-adminbox (resources/views/legacy/views/container-adminbox.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        components
        1
        title
        2
        attachNode
        3
        iconClass
        4
        id
        5
        class
        6
        formRenderService
      • legacy.views.container-view (resources/views/legacy/views/container-view.blade.php)6blade
        Params
        0
        components
        1
        controls
        2
        id
        3
        class
        4
        title
        5
        formRenderService
      • legacy.views.container-view (resources/views/legacy/views/container-view.blade.php)6blade
        Params
        0
        components
        1
        controls
        2
        id
        3
        class
        4
        title
        5
        formRenderService
      • app::layout.gadget (resources/views/layout/gadget.blade.php)2blade
        Params
        0
        contents
        1
        formRenderService
      • layout.columnstyle.two-right (resources/views/layout/columnstyle/two-right.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      • layout.columnstyle.componentstack (resources/views/layout/columnstyle/componentstack.blade.php)9blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        stack
        8
        component
      • layout.columnstyle.sidestack (resources/views/layout/columnstyle/sidestack.blade.php)9blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        stack
        8
        component
      • components.river.summary-list (resources/views/components/river/summary-list.blade.php)3blade
        Params
        0
        rivers
        1
        metrics
        2
        formRenderService
      • layout.main (resources/views/layout/main.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      • layout._headers (resources/views/layout/_headers.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      • layout.header (resources/views/layout/header.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      • layout._scripts (resources/views/layout/_scripts.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      • layout.navigation (resources/views/layout/navigation.blade.php)8blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        menu
      • includes.alert.membership (resources/views/includes/alert/membership.blade.php)17blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        menu
        8
        searchurl
        9
        loginurl
        10
        logouturl
        11
        __currentLoopData
        12
        child
        13
        loop
        14
        otherchild
        15
        shouldNotifyUser
        16
        user
      • navigation.menu.static (resources/views/navigation/menu/static.blade.php)15blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        menu
        8
        searchurl
        9
        loginurl
        10
        logouturl
        11
        __currentLoopData
        12
        child
        13
        loop
        14
        otherchild
      • includes.footer (resources/views/includes/footer.blade.php)8blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
        7
        menu
      • layout.pagemap (resources/views/layout/pagemap.blade.php)7blade
        Params
        0
        obLevel
        1
        __env
        2
        app
        3
        errors
        4
        contents
        5
        formRenderService
        6
        layout
      uri
      GET content/{url}
      middleware
      web
      controller
      App\Http\Controllers\Wh2oController@content
      namespace
      App\Http\Controllers
      where
      as
      generated::Os9R4mqMKRF5ktoI
      file
      app/Http/Controllers/Wh2oController.php:34-68
      28 statements were executed, 14 of which were duplicated, 14 unique156ms
      • select * from "articles" where ("id" = '30852' or "short_name" = '30852') and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        660μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. 30852
        • 1. 30852
        • 2. true
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1178
      • select * from linker_gadgets
        246μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:391
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/LinksInfo.php:23
        • 9. /app/MetaControllers/LinkerMetaController.php:138
      • select * from linker_gadgets
        123μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:391
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/LinksInfo.php:23
        • 9. /app/MetaControllers/LinkerMetaController.php:138
      • select l.sourcecomp, l.sourceid, l.targetcomp, l.targetid, l.mutual, l.expire_date, l.id from linker_lists l left join linker_gadgets g on l.targetcomp = g.source where (l.sourcecomp = 'article' and (l.sourceid = '30852' or g.is_list =0 )) or (l.targetcomp = 'article' and l.targetid='30852' and l.mutual = 1 )
        4.34ms/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:391
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/LinksInfo.php:113
        • 9. /app/MetaControllers/LinkerMetaController.php:213
      • select * from projects where deleted_at is null and ( id='3' or short_name = '3' )
        337μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:375
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/ProjectInfo.php:13
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ProjectGadget.inc:151
      • select r.id as rid,* from reach_map r where r.id in ('1049','3446','3101') ;
        106ms/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:391
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/RiverInfo.php:277
        • 9. /app/MetaControllers/RiverCollectionMetaController.php:20
      • select max(ed.event_date),l.targetid as id from linker_lists as l left join event_dates as ed on ed.event_id::char(10) = l.sourceid where l.targetid in ('3446','3101','1049') and l.targetcomp = 'river' and l.sourcecomp = 'event' and ed.event_date > now() group by l.targetid union select max(ed.event_date),l.sourceid as id from linker_lists as l left join event_dates as ed on ed.event_id::char(10) = l.targetid where l.sourceid in ('3446','3101','1049') and l.targetcomp = 'event' and l.sourcecomp = 'river' and ed.event_date > now() group by l.sourceid
        867μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:415
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/RiverInfo.php:822
        • 9. /app/Legacy/Repositories/RiverInfo.php:1080
      • select max(post_date),reach_id as id from posts c where c.post_type=502 and c.reach_id in (3446,3101,1049) and c.post_date > now()- ( interval '1 year') group by reach_id
        11.8ms/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:415
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/RiverInfo.php:786
        • 9. /app/Legacy/Repositories/RiverInfo.php:1081
      • SELECT id, member_id, abstract, city, state, url, expiration, email, volunteer_id, affiliates.members, contact, description, reaches, name FROM affiliates where deleted_at is null and id = 743215
        345μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:375
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:21
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • select reachid from affiliates_reaches where affiliateid=743215
        193μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:415
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:28
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • SELECT id, member_id, abstract, city, state, url, expiration, email, volunteer_id, affiliates.members, contact, description, reaches, name FROM affiliates where deleted_at is null and id = 3738
        301μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:375
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:21
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • SELECT id, member_id, abstract, city, state, url, expiration, email, volunteer_id, affiliates.members, contact, description, reaches, name FROM affiliates where deleted_at is null and id = 2532
        233μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:375
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:21
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • select reachid from affiliates_reaches where affiliateid=2532
        154μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:415
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:28
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • SELECT id, member_id, abstract, city, state, url, expiration, email, volunteer_id, affiliates.members, contact, description, reaches, name FROM affiliates where deleted_at is null and id = 279
        247μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:375
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:21
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • select reachid from affiliates_reaches where affiliateid=279
        154μs/vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476legacy db
        Metadata
        Backtrace
        • 4. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/helpers.php:476
        • 6. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:368
        • 7. /app/Legacy/Repositories/InfoADO.php:415
        • 8. /app/Legacy/Repositories/AffiliateInfo.php:28
        • 9. /code/wh2o/ClubGadget.inc:174
      • select * from "articles" where ("id" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' or "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain') and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        490μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 1. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 2. true
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' limit 1
        350μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where "articles"."id" = '30852' and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        410μs/app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. 30852
        • 1. true
        Backtrace
        • 19. /app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89
        • 20. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:283
        • 21. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:198
        • 22. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 23. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
      • select * from "articles" where "articles"."id" = '30852' and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        440μs/app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. 30852
        • 1. true
        Backtrace
        • 19. /app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89
        • 20. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:283
        • 21. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:199
        • 22. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 23. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
      • select * from "articles" where "articles"."id" = '30852' and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        9.35ms/app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. 30852
        • 1. true
        Backtrace
        • 19. /app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89
        • 20. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:283
        • 21. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:290
        • 22. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:250
        • 23. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
      • select * from "articles" where ("id" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' or "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain') and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        550μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 1. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 2. true
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' limit 1
        320μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where ("id" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' or "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain') and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        420μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 1. -SecurityGadget-explain
        • 2. true
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:61
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where "short_name" = '-SecurityGadget-explain' limit 1
        340μs/app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. -SecurityGadget-explain
        Backtrace
        • 15. /app/Legacy/Repositories/NewsInfo.php:64
        • 16. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:128
        • 17. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:930
        • 18. /code/wh2o/Page1.inc:1019
        • 19. /code/wh2o/SecurityGadget.inc:150
      • select * from "articles" where "articles"."id" = '30852' and "articles"."deleted_at" is null and "articles"."is_final" = 'true' limit 1
        9.05ms/app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. 30852
        • 1. true
        Backtrace
        • 19. /app/MetaControllers/NewsMetaController.php:89
        • 20. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:283
        • 21. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:396
        • 22. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:439
        • 23. /code/wh2o/ArticleGadget.inc:338
      • select * from "geo_states" where "geo_states"."gmi" = 'USA-NCR' limit 1
        370μsview::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. USA-NCR
        Backtrace
        • 19. view::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17
        • 21. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:57
        • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:139
        • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:122
        • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:91
      • select * from "geo_states" where "geo_states"."gmi" = 'USA-GEO' limit 1
        7.37msview::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. USA-GEO
        Backtrace
        • 19. view::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17
        • 21. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:57
        • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:139
        • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:122
        • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:91
      • select * from "geo_states" where "geo_states"."gmi" = 'USA-GEO' limit 1
        350μsview::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17wh2o
        Metadata
        Bindings
        • 0. USA-GEO
        Backtrace
        • 19. view::431006a3df29e007636b99b8f2357411f319a4c2:17
        • 21. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:57
        • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:139
        • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:122
        • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/View.php:91
      App\State
      3
      App\Article
      5
          _token
          5Lz7djrZ3Ezv3UlR8sN8tZYOEUQhWveSd5UvwYEP
          pref
          []
          page
          array:1 [ "count" => 9 ]
          PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA
          []
          _previous
          array:1 [ "url" => "https://beta.americanwhitewater.org/content/Article/view/article_id/30092/disp...
          _flash
          array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ]
          path_info
          /content/Article/view/article_id/30852/display/full
          status_code
          200
          
          status_text
          OK
          format
          html
          content_type
          text/html; charset=UTF-8
          request_query
          []
          
          request_request
          []
          
          request_headers
          0 of 0
          array:16 [ "cookie" => array:1 [ 0 => "PHPSESSID=up0g5sbb75ecdu5688o98915ar; XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImZlZ0lKSHg3eWd1bEVMWExjSFA5RHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZElicjBDeFNWa0pXODZpYXdvMGZkekJBdjNpaWVnTjdmZE52VzJxdktNdVFGajluOHFBSVA3OTBIMHhQcGlGa24zTHBrQlZ1N1VCZy8vTmtOdllVRTZaekNERVQ2UzQrSndGbTJhM1NsUkpRbUVldXJWSFR5bkRhRTJzdFpoK0siLCJtYWMiOiI1ZTFjZDI5YmU2OTA1M2UxNDI3NzVlY2M5ZjY5YjkyMzgzYWRkODg4NWIzMTZiZjRiNzI2N2NlMjIzZTA1OTQwIn0%3D; americanwhitewater_session=jhhUwJuDdDYdwvNYk4qaNAyCn8FhO7XzEByTmWU6PHPSESSID=up0g5sbb75ecdu5688o98915ar; XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImZlZ0lKSHg3eWd1bEVMWExjSFA5RHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZElicjBDeFNWa0pXODZpYXdvMGZkekJBdjNpaWVnTjdmZE52VzJxdkt" ] "priority" => array:1 [ 0 => "u=0, i" ] "accept-encoding" => array:1 [ 0 => "gzip, deflate, br, zstd" ] "sec-fetch-dest" => array:1 [ 0 => "document" ] "sec-fetch-user" => array:1 [ 0 => "?1" ] "sec-fetch-mode" => array:1 [ 0 => "navigate" ] "sec-fetch-site" => array:1 [ 0 => "none" ] "accept" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" ] "user-agent" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" ] "upgrade-insecure-requests" => array:1 [ 0 => "1" ] "sec-ch-ua-platform" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Windows"" ] "sec-ch-ua-mobile" => array:1 [ 0 => "?0" ] "sec-ch-ua" => array:1 [ 0 => ""HeadlessChrome";v="129", "Not=A?Brand";v="8", "Chromium";v="129"" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "host" => array:1 [ 0 => "beta.americanwhitewater.org" ] ]
          request_server
          0 of 0
          array:43 [ "USER" => "www-data" "HOME" => "/var/www" "HTTP_COOKIE" => "PHPSESSID=up0g5sbb75ecdu5688o98915ar; XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImZlZ0lKSHg3eWd1bEVMWExjSFA5RHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZElicjBDeFNWa0pXODZpYXdvMGZkekJBdjNpaWVnTjdmZE52VzJxdktNdVFGajluOHFBSVA3OTBIMHhQcGlGa24zTHBrQlZ1N1VCZy8vTmtOdllVRTZaekNERVQ2UzQrSndGbTJhM1NsUkpRbUVldXJWSFR5bkRhRTJzdFpoK0siLCJtYWMiOiI1ZTFjZDI5YmU2OTA1M2UxNDI3NzVlY2M5ZjY5YjkyMzgzYWRkODg4NWIzMTZiZjRiNzI2N2NlMjIzZTA1OTQwIn0%3D; americanwhitewater_session=jhhUwJuDdDYdwvNYk4qaNAyCn8FhO7XzEByTmWU6PHPSESSID=up0g5sbb75ecdu5688o98915ar; XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImZlZ0lKSHg3eWd1bEVMWExjSFA5RHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZElicjBDeFNWa0pXODZpYXdvMGZkekJBdjNpaWVnTjdmZE52VzJxdkt" "HTTP_PRIORITY" => "u=0, i" "HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING" => "gzip, deflate, br, zstd" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_DEST" => "document" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_USER" => "?1" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_MODE" => "navigate" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_SITE" => "none" "HTTP_ACCEPT" => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" "HTTP_USER_AGENT" => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" "HTTP_UPGRADE_INSECURE_REQUESTS" => "1" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_PLATFORM" => ""Windows"" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_MOBILE" => "?0" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA" => ""HeadlessChrome";v="129", "Not=A?Brand";v="8", "Chromium";v="129"" "HTTP_CACHE_CONTROL" => "no-cache" "HTTP_PRAGMA" => "no-cache" "HTTP_HOST" => "beta.americanwhitewater.org" "REDIRECT_STATUS" => "200" "SERVER_NAME" => "beta.americanwhitewater.org" "SERVER_PORT" => "443" "SERVER_ADDR" => "172.31.18.125" "REMOTE_PORT" => "30156" "REMOTE_ADDR" => "18.188.115.61" "SERVER_SOFTWARE" => "nginx/1.18.0" "GATEWAY_INTERFACE" => "CGI/1.1" "HTTPS" => true "REQUEST_SCHEME" => "https" "SERVER_PROTOCOL" => "HTTP/2.0" "DOCUMENT_ROOT" => "/opt/americanwhitewater.org/public" "DOCUMENT_URI" => "/index.php" "REQUEST_URI" => "/content/Article/view/article_id/30852/display/full" "SCRIPT_NAME" => "/index.php" "CONTENT_LENGTH" => "" "CONTENT_TYPE" => "" "REQUEST_METHOD" => "GET" "QUERY_STRING" => "" "PHP_VALUE" => "post_max_size=20M" "SCRIPT_FILENAME" => "/opt/americanwhitewater.org/public/index.php" "FCGI_ROLE" => "RESPONDER" "PHP_SELF" => "/index.php" "REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT" => 1743859167.6121 "REQUEST_TIME" => 1743859167 ]
          request_cookies
          0 of 0
          array:3 [ "PHPSESSID" => null "XSRF-TOKEN" => "5Lz7djrZ3Ezv3UlR8sN8tZYOEUQhWveSd5UvwYEP" "americanwhitewater_session" => null ]
          response_headers
          0 of 0
          array:5 [ "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html; charset=UTF-8" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache, private" ] "date" => array:1 [ 0 => "Sat, 05 Apr 2025 13:19:28 GMT" ] "set-cookie" => array:1 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik5XdHJybDBCVHBabEVIOUJ2Q21oMHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoic1ZuN1R0TkVWeEFsZmordHZqUkdNN1I0dFBSc0VTTnJGWjBEREVpdXRzV2p2OHVtbkEzcXFRNzFtN1Zxb0I1TmZQOWY0K0VSRHY1eGdGK0ppSFRROUNWZlQxQ2hrMkNBVTl0dWt1WWtxZldCcitXU3huMEhvbjhtZ3IxY0hEdFYiLCJtYWMiOiJjNTg4YTk5YmE0NjAxZGY5OGIyMTliOGRlY2RlNmVhYTc1ODdmY2VjNWIzZmUzMWVjYzVlMmNjOTkxOTk1OWNlIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 05-Apr-2025 15:19:28 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik5XdHJybDBCVHBabEVIOUJ2Q21oMHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoic1ZuN1R0TkVWeEFsZmordHZqUkdNN1I0dFBSc0VTTnJGWjBEREVpdXRzV2p2OHVtbkEzcXFRNzFtN1Zxb0I1TmZQOWY0K" ] "Set-Cookie" => array:1 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik5XdHJybDBCVHBabEVIOUJ2Q21oMHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoic1ZuN1R0TkVWeEFsZmordHZqUkdNN1I0dFBSc0VTTnJGWjBEREVpdXRzV2p2OHVtbkEzcXFRNzFtN1Zxb0I1TmZQOWY0K0VSRHY1eGdGK0ppSFRROUNWZlQxQ2hrMkNBVTl0dWt1WWtxZldCcitXU3huMEhvbjhtZ3IxY0hEdFYiLCJtYWMiOiJjNTg4YTk5YmE0NjAxZGY5OGIyMTliOGRlY2RlNmVhYTc1ODdmY2VjNWIzZmUzMWVjYzVlMmNjOTkxOTk1OWNlIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 05-Apr-2025 15:19:28 GMT; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik5XdHJybDBCVHBabEVIOUJ2Q21oMHc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoic1ZuN1R0TkVWeEFsZmordHZqUkdNN1I0dFBSc0VTTnJGWjBEREVpdXRzV2p2OHVtbkEzcXFRNzFtN1Zxb0I1TmZQOWY0K" ] ]
          session_attributes
          0 of 0
          array:6 [ "_token" => "5Lz7djrZ3Ezv3UlR8sN8tZYOEUQhWveSd5UvwYEP" "pref" => [] "page" => array:1 [ "count" => 9 ] "PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA" => [] "_previous" => array:1 [ "url" => "https://beta.americanwhitewater.org/content/Article/view/article_id/30092/display/full" ] "_flash" => array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ] ]